Red Alert

Posts Tagged ‘university’

Is cradle to the grave education under further threat?

Posted by Kelvin Davis on January 15th, 2010

Universities are going to boot under-performing students out of university to free up places for able students.  Universities  can’t afford to ‘carry’ the under-performing students.

I’m concerned about the effect this will have for Maori in particular. We struggle to get Maori into university as it is, but now for those who do get there it’s going to be easier to get booted out.

I remember my mate from the coast who spent (at least) nine years getting his law degree. Now I bump in to him at the airport occasionally as he flies around from one high powered meeting to the next.

I’m blowed if I know why he took so long, but he hung in there and now he’s doing really well.

If he’d been booted out because he failed courses then he’d probably be pumping gas in Nowhereville and Maori wouldn’t be benefiting from his services.

He subscribed to the theory if at first you don’t succeed then try and try again.

What are the solutions? I don’t want capable and deserving people to miss out on places at university, but I don’t want people like my mate getting the boot.

The other concern is the threat to automatic entry to people over twenty years of age. This really affects Maori. Many Maori have bad experiences at school and drop out of education. Many often come back later in life, enter university and get qualifications that take them in a new direction.

Is cradle to the grave education under threat?


Another 1990s failure back on the agenda

Posted by Chris Hipkins on July 27th, 2009

Twelve years ago as a first year university student I attended my first ever student protest march. The 25th of September 1997 has stuck in my mind ever since because it was the first and only time I have been arrested. Thankfully neither the District Court nor the High Court agreed with the Police decision to arrest 75 of us for trespass while we were protesting in parliament grounds.

It was an important test case because it confirmed the principle that all citizens have the right to protest peacefully at parliament. That case finally came to a conclusion a few weeks ago when the Police agreed to pay compensation and parliament’s speaker (which was actually Doug Kidd at the time) agreed to issue apologies.

Twelve years later, it’s interesting to see the issues that led to that protest march once again emerging from the new National government. Back in 1997 the then Bolger-led National government released a Green Paper on tertiary education. They proposed to introduce a corporatized, pro-market system for university and polytechnic funding. Democratically elected governing councils made up of stakeholders were to be replaced by boards of directors appointed by the government.

The Tertiary Review Green Paper followed hot on the heels of Max Bradford’s pro-market electricity reforms and came at a time when the public had tired of the privatisation agenda. It was yet another sign that the National government’s continued trumpeting of the New Right free market agenda was out of step with ordinary New Zealanders. Two years later Helen Clark’s Labour team comfortably won the 1999 general election.

Interesting to see, therefore, that the new Minister of Education Anne Tolley is putting some of those issues back on the table. The Sunday Star Times reports the government plans a radical overhaul of polytechnic governance, dumping about 250 of the 400 existing councillors. Maori and Pasifika representatives would be axed, along with representatives of employers, unions, and former students.

Tolley’s decision to resuscitate elements of the controversial and failed Tertiary Review Green Paper reforms is another signal that pro-market corporatisation and privatisation is firmly back on the government’s agenda. Education will be viewed as a commodity to be bought and sold, while students will be viewed as consumers, not learners.

Twelve years ago my opposition to these very reforms compelled me to join a protest march. What happened next was one of the key events that led me towards a life in politics. When Tolley brings her legislation before parliament, this time I won’t just be protesting outside, I’ll be fighting her every step of the way inside the House too.


Questions To Members Today

Posted by Trevor Mallard on July 21st, 2009

Teaser continues:-

Questions to Members

Hon MARYAN STREET to the Chairperson of the Education and Science Committee: Is the question of considering whether to forward a supplementary question on the Estimates for 2009/10 relating to advice the Ministry of Education or Tertiary Education Commission provided relating to the Budget’s funding of universities on the Committee’s agenda for its next meeting?

MOANA MACKEY to the Chairperson of the Education and Science Committee: Is the question of considering whether to forward a supplementary question on the Estimates for 2009/10 relating to advice the Ministry of Education or Tertiary Education Commission provided relating to the Budget’s impact on regional and rural polytechnics on the Committee’s agenda for its next meeting?

CARMEL SEPULONI to the Chairperson of the Education and Science Committee: Is the question of considering whether to forward a supplementary question on the Estimates for 2009/10 relating to advice the Ministry of Education or Tertiary Education Commission provided relating to the supplying of Cabinet papers on the youth guarantee scheme on the Committee’s agenda for its next meting?

KELVIN DAVIS to the Chairperson of the Education and Science Committee: Is the question of considering whether to forward a supplementary question on the Estimates for 2009/10 relating to advice the Ministry of Education has provided on each of the expenditure reductions within Vote Education on the Committee’s agenda for its next meeting?