Red Alert

Posts Tagged ‘Nanny state’

In defence of sick leave

Posted by on July 24th, 2010

This week a few wags (on both sides of the House) had a laugh at my expense as I struggled through a couple of speeches and an oral question with a pretty bad cold. Fair call, I probably would have been better to stay at home in bed rather than solider on and spread my germs around the place. But that’s the Kiwi way, isn’t it? Stay at home to recover and you’re ‘soft’ and need to ‘toughen up’. If it’s good enough for Colin Meads to play on with a broken arm, surely we can put up with a bit of cold and flu?

Well actually, that’s a pretty crap attitude. Most of the time we’d be better to spend a day or two in bed, get rid of our germs, and then head back to work. That way we’d avoid spreading our bug and probably be back to full health a lot quicker. If we went to work while crook we’re probably not that productive anyway.

So why on earth does the National government feel the need to perpetuate the idea that anyone who takes a day off to get better is shirking? John Key’s suggestion that someone taking a single day of sick leave could be forced to go to their GP to get a ‘note’ is just stupid. Here in Upper Hutt it’s almost impossible to get an appointment with a GP anyway. Not content with loading them up with the burden of dishing out cold and flu pills, now John ‘the Nanny’ Key wants them to sign-off every sore throat, runny nose, or headache…


The blackberry is handsfree

Posted by on October 11th, 2009

My van has never had a handsfree but Steven Joyce’s nanny state approach has forced me to install one.

Interesting thing for me is that because it is mounted on the dash sort of above the steering wheel  it is really easy to read texts and emails. Couldn’t do that when it sat on the passenger seat or in my pocket between phone calls.

Will have to avoid the temptation but I’m not sure it is a great step for road safety.


Gerry’s Energy Spot Campaign

Posted by on September 24th, 2009

I just attended the launch of a high profile campaign to help New Zealanders increase the energy efficiency of their homes and businesses. The new prime time campaign, called The Energy Spot, will screen three nights a week on four TV channels as well as at 13 random times throughout the week. The campaign is costing $4million to run over the next 12 months.

Here are a few details from Gerry Brownlee’s media release:

“The Energy Spot will cover a range of topics of interest to households and businesses, from insulating houses to efficient driving choices, renewable energy options, building design and more.

“This new campaign will give large numbers of people clear, practical information to help them make the most of the energy they use both at home and at work.

I actually support the idea that the government has a role to play in providing New Zealanders with information and practical advice on ways to reduce their energy use. However I can’t help but think that if this campaign had been launched 12 months ago it would have been greeted with howls of ‘nanny state’ and ‘telling us how to live our lives’ by the then National opposition. I can just hear Allan Peachy rallying against this ‘socialism by stealth’.

In the past few months I’ve come to the realisation that the National Party is actually a bit of a fan of the nanny state. They want to tell people what they are and aren’t allowed to do in their own cars, they’re telling everyone to stomach cuts they aren’t willing to make for themselves, and now we have this. Seems it’s not the idea of the nanny state that National was opposed to, just the idea that they weren’t doing the nannying.