Red Alert

Posts Tagged ‘Flag’

Time for a republic?

Posted by Chris Hipkins on October 16th, 2010

Last night former Wallaby Peter FitzSimons gave a fantastic opening address to the Labour Party Annual Conference. Usually the President gives the opening address, but this year we tried something a bit different. FitzSimons was incredibly funny but also raised some pretty big issues.  

He praised New Zealand’s decision not to go to war with Iraq and repeatedly stressed how important an independent foreign policy should be to both our countries. Noting growing support on both sides of the ditch for our respective countries to become republics, he argued passionately in favour of a change of flag, recalling Seinfeld’s joke about the Aussie flag being “Great Britain at night” (not to mention the number of Kiwis and Aussies who can’t tell our flags apart…)

I’m a strong supporter of a New Zealand republic. I don’t think it’s something that we will gradually evolve towards, I think it’s something we should be actively discussing and working to achieve. But I don’t think it’s a decision for politicians to make. I think we need to lead the debate, but all New Zealanders should make the final decision by way of a referendum.

I strongly agree with FitzSimons’ observation that we shouldn’t link our debate about republicanism with the reign of the current monarch:

“As a sovereign nation we shouldn’t be deciding our politics on the health of an elderly English woman. She’s a good woman, no doubt about it. But we should be carving out our independent way.”

I was disappointed that Keith Locke’s private members bill was voted down. It would have given all New Zealanders a chance to have a say on whether or not NZ should become a republic. I also agree with our President Andrew Little who said “It’s a cop-out to say, ‘Yes, I’m a republican, but it’s not time’, that it be left up to somebody else…That’s a failure of leadership, in my view”.


Is John Key racist for criticising Hone Harawira but backing Wiremu Pakeha?

Posted by Trevor Mallard on February 5th, 2010

Kelvin Davis has posted on whether it is appropriate to copyright the Maori Party flag. Interesting discussion but it now appears  that neither Hone Harawira nor his wife has any beneficial interest in any application that may be made in the future.

So why has John Key been so aggressive in his criticism of Hone?

Hone is a sometimes an easy target. He puts his head up and I’ve certainly had a go at him when it is appropriate.

But contrast this question of a perceived (but not actual) conflict of interest of a member of Hone’s family with the decade of the English whanau ripping the taxpayer off by pretending to live in Dipton. And Wiremu was found to have an interest. And it is continuing.

So is Key kicking Hone because he is Maori and if not what is his explanation for his hypocrisy?


How to cheapen the Maori Flag

Posted by Kelvin Davis on February 5th, 2010

I’m not too fussed about Hone’s family selling the Tino Rangatiratanga flag. Shops have been selling the New Zealand flag for years and someone makes a profit from it, so let’s not have double standards for the Maori flag.

I do object to the flag design being copyrighted or individuals/families having IP rights.

Here’s some thoughts:

  1. It was all about mana, not money.
  2. No one was told the series of flag consultation hui doubled as a taxpayer funded promotion for some whanau flag making business promotion.
  3. If someone can own the flag, it’s copyright and have intellectual property rights over it, does that mean they have authority over where and when it’s flown?
  4. Can the owners of the copyright then stop all production of the flag making them scarce and then drive the price of the flag up to maximise profits?
  5. Could someone else then buy the flag’s copyright off the owners and it becomes a tradeable commodity?
  6. If I bought the copyright and IP rights, could I then auction it on Trade Me?
  7. If a single whanau owns it, how can Maori then say it belongs to us all?
  8. Doesn’t putting a price on the flag actually cheapen it?
  9. Isn’t this more evidence that the consultation and selection process was a set up from the start?
  10. Would we accept the New Zealand flag being owned by one family?
  11. Have we all noticed how shocking the Maori unemployment figures are and that the Maori Party and National have done nothing to address this issue that really affects Maori families?
Tags:
Filed under: M?ori

Hone may have done some good

Posted by Trevor Mallard on December 21st, 2009

Hone getting John Key to agree to making the Maori Party flag an official flag of New Zealand may have done some good. It has rekindled the issue of getting a real New Zealand flag – not one designed for minor adjustment when we joined Australia – as many thought inevitable at the time. It would be good to have a flag that brings Kiwis together rather than two that drive us apart.

To vote on your favourite go to John Ansell’s site. Health warning – this is the Iwi/Kiwi guy, if you are easily offended by right wing rubbish don’t go there, or hold your nose as you vote.

Hat tip Kiwiblog.


A new New Zealand flag

Posted by Kelvin Davis on August 14th, 2009

One of the first things I might do when Labour is next in government, is over two or three months hold up to 21 meetings in community halls around the country to get people to choose a new New Zealand flag.

After intensive consultation amongst Labour colleagues we’ll have four flag options for New Zealanders to choose from.

  1. The current New Zealand flag
  2. The New Zealand Red Ensign
  3. The flag of the United Tribes
  4. The Tino Rangatiratanga flag

At the end of the day I’m not too fussed about which flag is chosen. It’s about building unity through ensuring everybody gets a say.


Flags replace beads and blankets

Posted by Chris Hipkins on July 20th, 2009

Our colleague Shane Jones has a very thought provoking column in this morning’s Dominion Post regarding the choice of flag to fly over the Auckland Harbour Bridge on Waitangi Day next year. It’s titled “Flags taking the place of blankets and beads”. I can’t find it online, but here are some excerpts:

“Maori have enjoyed flags since before the Treaty of Waitangi. In the midst of the Maori land wars, tribal leaders believed in the power of flags … The Crown regularly presented flags to tribes for their loyalty. Colonists did so as well. In 1864 a flag was presented to the tribes of Wanganui for protecting the Wanganui township from their upper river kin Moutoa.

“Prime Minister John Key is maintaining that historic tradition as he rewards the Maori Party for loyalty, and sanctions the Maori Affairs minister to fund gatherings to select a flag…Mr Key has done an impressive job in capturing the Maori Party. He is canny enough to know it is less threatening and more amusing to have hui about independence ensigns than confront Maori state dependency. Beads and blankets are no longer de rigueur – rather it is flags that are the new currency.”

“Mr Key knows that hoisting a flag above the harbour bridge will not alter one jot Maori economic status. The 500 Maori losing their jobs every week know that getting their whänau up the ladder is the true test of rangatiratanga…”

“Maori fortunes are inextricably bound up with those of society overall. Far more prosaic, less mesmerising topics such as productivity, numeracy, literacy, civic participation jobs and employment are responsibilities that the Maori Party is shirking.