Red Alert

Posts Tagged ‘economic development’

Economic Development

Posted by on February 28th, 2013

David Shearer has been clear from the start that he wants a clean, green, diversified economy – to ensure New Zealand’s future prosperity.

With my appointment as Economic Development Spokeperson comes a big challenge. We need to present a credible plan to get to a prosperous diversified economy.  I’m excited about this opportunity.

Steven Joyce spent a year with the huge bureaucratic resources of MoBIE and failed to map anything but a managed decline. His ‘Business Growth Agenda’ finalised yesterday has proven little more that a year long coms plan. It’s been a year of existing policy re-heats with a few meek ideas thrown in for colour.

But Joyce is vulnerable. Because the facts are drowning out his spin.

Last year 30,000 jobs were lost.  Unemployment is pushing 7%.  1000+ Kiwis are leaving for Australia permanently every week.

No amount of spin can hide the fact that the Government has no plan for sustainable economic growth. Selling off our best revenue-generating assets is National’s big idea.  Treasury says it will set back the Government coffers by about $100m/year. Other than that, they intend things to continue as they are.

I’ve always maintained that the market makes an excellent servant and a terrible master. And this Government is failing to control the market. It is failing to deliver jobs. Right now so many hard-working New Zealanders are being treated like its slaves, forced to be grateful for any scraps that fall from the table. A full 40% of Kiwis earn less than a living wage.

Labour already has chunky policy announced that will lead to economic growth, jobs and an export-led recovery. In particular we want a pro-growth capital gains tax, Research and Develoment Tax Credits, Universal Kiwisaver, Pro-Kiwi procurement policy and tools for the Reserve Bank that will allow it to do what overseas countries are doing to assist their exporters.  These changes will give the economy a shot in the arm and create jobs.

There is more to explore.  Sector-specific incentives for growth beg consideration, as do the implications of Labour’s affordable and healthy housing announcements.  They will create jobs as will our commitment to creating more apprenticeships.  Labour wants a market that generates jobs, living wages and future prosperity for our country.

We need change, because the old solutions have been shown to fail. Right now, the market and it’s hands-off disciple Mr Joyce are not working in the interest of New Zealanders.


Steven Joyce Can’t Count

Posted by on February 29th, 2012

An embarrassing slip occurred by Steven Joyce in the House today.

When I asked in a supplementary to his own patsy question by how many billion the current account defict was forecast to deteriorate over the next four years, he said “less than 5″ and said he based the estimate on the PREFU (Treasury’s pre-election fiscal update).

The actual number in the PREFU is down to $17.6 billion. Nowhere close to sub $5 bn. He then blamed the earthquake for the deterioration. In fact, the PREFU forecasts estimate only a quarter of the deterioration as eathquake related.

Mr Joyce has not corrected the errors – which is required under standing orders at the earliest opportuity.

His problem is that reducing the current account deficit is one of the most basic goals of economic development policy. Not knowingthe headline numbers is embarrasssing. Just making it up is downright risky.

This is the same minister busily negotiating “deals” with corporates, casinos and media moguls. I wonder how many Kiwis would trust his financial nous if he keeps fluffing the numbers?

Bill English is smiling inside.


Should this be the way forward for NZ?

Posted by on February 21st, 2010

Whirlpool plans to start closing its refrigerator plant in Evansville, Indiana, on 26 March eliminating 1,100 local jobs. It has decided to shift its operation to Mexico. Why? Lower labour costs.

As the world’s largest home appliance maker, Whirlpool makes a healthy profit.

The AFL CIO (our CTU equivalent) reports Whirlpool has has received a $19 million economic matching grant that should be creating jobs  in America. They’ve started a petition to Keep it made in America

Sound familiar?

In April 2008 Fisher and Paykel announced about 1,000 jobs, or 28 percent of the total work force, would be lost in New Zealand, Australia and the northern United States as plants were relocated to Mexico, Thailand and Italy, where a similar number of new jobs would be created.

Fisher and Paykel said at the time that labour costs in Mexico were about a sixth of those in New Zealand.

Sooo… what happens next time there’s a plan to outsource, offshore, a lot of NZ jobs?

Or, next time there’s the potential to create and provide certainty for a bunch of jobs in New Zealand through investment in local infrastructure, such as the electrification of Auckland rail.

Are cheaper labour costs (in China, Mexico) the bottom line? Or should our economic development rest upon a wider set of values? Maintaining and building skills. Encouraging local innovation. Building our own export base. Keeping kiwi jobs kiwi.

And what should the role of government be?