Red Alert

Posts Tagged ‘Chris Carter’

Sad caucus

Posted by Trevor Mallard on July 29th, 2010

Don’t normally post things about caucus here but this is going to lead the news so I figure it is ok.

Made it clear in the past that Chris Carter and I were never that close. We argued. West coast snails probably the worst.

But I’ve got to know him pretty well over the last couple of years. We go to pump classes together. The Labour Party and Parliament have been Chris’ life for the last 17 years.

Chris has been under a lot of pressure around the expense issue. He hasn’t found it easy to take that pressure. I haven’t supported him well.

Today he did something incredibly stupid (made stuff up and circulated it to media in a failed attempt to be anonymous) which I think has ended his political career. He has been suspended from our caucus. Quite a few of us who can sometimes be pretty hard had tears in our eyes as we did it.

But as with sport when there is an extremely bad breech of team discipline you are dropped from the team. Our teams decision was unanimous.


Give Chris some space

Posted by Trevor Mallard on June 16th, 2010

Those close to Labour politics know that Chris Carter and I have never been that close. Both Labour to the core but different approaches. Some intense discussions – big West Coast snails being a classic – Chris went with advice that there were only a few hundred – after we spent millions it turned out there were tens of thousands  and we weren’t even allowed to eat them!

I don’t accept the view that he is picked on because he is gay. He is picked on because there is a common view that he has travelled too much. But there is no doubt that lots of people are putting an extra boot into Chris because he is gay. One only has to look at Whaleoil (yes I did) or many comments on Kiwiblog to see the bile that homophobes  are writing.

All of us make mistakes in our jobs. Sometimes we don’t see it. I’ve had a few examples. Would have been better for my career if I didn’t call Tau Uncle Tom or if I kept some space between us.

But my classic was probably around school closures. I was out of tune with public perception. I thought most people would prefer money to spent on education not underutilised buildings and would see the risk of kids only having two or three teachers though their primary schooling. I never saw the NZEI moving from supporting quality education to supporting a few principals who would lose their jobs. I got it wrong.

I think Chris is in a similar space. He worked really hard as a Minister. We both pushed very hard on international education like no Education  Ministers before and after and possibly harder than some of our colleagues wanted. We both believe that besides the economic boost the long term links and highly qualified migrants that flow can make a difference to New Zealand.

But the fact is that most Kiwis who have considered the issue are of the view that Chris travelled too much. And politics is all about perception. Deep down Chris knows that. And the mistakes that he and his staff have made are judged against that background.

I repeat we all make mistakes at work.

Chris is pretty badly hurt. And he is damaged. That is obvious. He has to decide what he wants to do.

My appeal is for us to be reasonable, forget the lynch mob mentality, and let him work out what is best for him, for Labour and for New Zealand.

And give him space to do that.

Warning this post will be tightly moderated. Homophobic comments will be deleted and their authors lose their right to comment for a period of time.


St Kitts and Nevis election monitoring

Posted by Chris Carter on January 19th, 2010

I’m heading off to St Kitts and Nevis tonight to lead the international Commonwealth team monitoring their elections.

It’s a real privilege to have been asked to carry out this important work by Commonwealth Secretary General Kamalesh Sharma. I guess it shows how respected New Zealand is in the world! We are one of the oldest democracies on earth, but I think that decisions taken by successive Labour Governments – such as our nuclear free policy and more recently keeping New Zealanders safe and out of the Iraq War – have really raised our global profile as a fair player and a strong defender of human rights.

Many New Zealanders may not have heard a lot about the small Caribbean nation of St Kitts and Nevis. It’s a really beautiful island chain with very friendly people, which I know because I represented New Zealand as Conservation Minister during the International Whaling Commission meeting there in 2006. But the country has suffered from corruption and the results of the last election there were hotly disputed. You can read more about St Kitts and Nevis at the CIA World Factbook.

United Nations Development Programme officials have asked to brief me about recent issues in Caribbean democracy and development before I arrive in the capital Basseterre, which will be really useful. There are some parallels between island-nation development in the Caribbean and closer to home here in our Pacific region.

St Kitts and Nevis is only an hour’s flight from Haiti, so I’m going to be paying a lot of attention to how the small states in the region have been able to respond to the terrible earthquake there. Many readers will remember that last year Luamanuvao Winnie Laban and I boarded the first flight to Samoa immediately following their devastating earthquake. If you ever have to hold a mother as she cries for her missing baby, as I did in Samoa, you’ll probably become as passionate about improving global disaster relief as I am.

I’m really hoping the St Kitts and Nevis election will run smoothly and properly, and that the free and fair will of the people will be expressed in the outcome without my intervention. I’ll look to report back to Red Alert readers after the results are in.

I’m likely to be gone for just under three weeks. My flights are being covered by the Commonwealth and I’ll meet any miscellaneous expenses myself so New Zealand taxpayers won’t foot any of the bill.


On Samoa

Posted by Winnie Laban on October 5th, 2009

15

Talofa lava, Warm Greetings,

Early on Wednesday morning, I heard the news of the earthquake and tsunami hitting Samoa. As more information came in about the impact of this disaster I knew that I must go to Samoa.

Phil Goff and Annette King, the Leader and Deputy Leader of the Labour Party, encouraged Chris Carter (Foreign Affairs Spokesperson) and I to go to Samoa. We did not want to make any fuss or attract any media interviews, we just went as soon as we could.

I took the first flight I could get to Auckland and at 2.20 pm we were on the plane to Samoa.

During the next two days we visited villages on the south coast: Lalomanu, Aleipata, Poutasi, Lepa, Falealili and many of the areas the tsunami devastated. We spent time at the Moto’otua Hospital.

We met with the Prime Minister Tuila’epa Sailele Malielegaoi and other Samoan Government officials. The Prime Minister asked us to attend a meeting of the Samoan National Disaster Coordination and Distribution Committee. I also spent time with Fiame Naomi Mata’afa, who is Minister responsible for village councils. We talked about how best to help.

I went to offer my alofa, support and encouragement. In difficult times we must be with our people.

You have all seen the photographs in the newspapers and on the television. You have heard the voices on the radio. You will all know what things look like in Samoa.

Seeing what had happened on the ground was deeply disturbing. Fale wrecked, villages in ruin, bodies on the beach. People were scared, traumatised, and in shock.

What the news coverage does not show is the spirit and faith of our people. The alofa, fa’aaloalo, and agaga. Love, reciprocity, and spirituality. And our deep belief in God’s love and strength.

I was so proud to see the way that Samoans, who were suffering, were looking after the New Zealanders, Australians and others who had suffered alongside them. And in turn New Zealanders and Australians were supporting Samoans. It was great to see that the Kiwi spirit is strong and everybody was working well together.

I was proud to be a Samoan and a New Zealander. I was encouraged by the way that we become one people in these difficult days.

On Thursday morning we attended the funeral service of Tui Annandale. It was the first of many.

Then my cousin Imo Tuatagaloa took us in his taxi to visit Moto’otua Hospital, and the villages on the South coast.

In the hospital many people were being treated for their injuries and recovering from the physical and emotional trauma. I met a Samoan woman who had lost two of her grandchildren. We met New Zealanders who had lost children and other family members. One Kiwi couple had lost their two and half year old child.

In the villages we met Samoans who had lost ten or more family members. The Taufua family in Lalomanu had lost three generations of their family. The Faifeau in Poutasi had lost his wife.

The loss is great. So many people have lost everything.

The people I talked to asked for support to come direct: family-to-family, village-to-village, church-to-church.

I am sure that families, community organisations, and the Government will raise money and provide the assistance that Samoa needs to survive and recover. But I know that it will be the spirit of the Samoan people that will keep them strong

In time the villages will be rebuilt. The scars on the landscape will soon be smoothed away. The trees and plants will grow again. Schools, churches and businesses will be re-established.

It will take much longer to heal the loss of family and friends. Those who we have lost will be with us forever.

“Inside us our dead, our dead are the proud robes our souls wear.”
“We are the remembered cord
that stretches across the abyss
of all that we have forgotten
We don’t inherit the past
But a creation of our remembering.”

Let us remember those we have lost in this disaster.

Let us stand with our people during this time of suffering and give them support, hope, and encouragement.

Let us work together to rebuild Samoa.

Tatou te momoe ma manu ae lilo mala e ati a’e.

E tagi le fatu ma le ‘ele’ele O le puapuaga, ae to’a i le Atua lona filemu.

f

b

a

c

d

e

g

i


Labour’s proud green credentials

Posted by Chris Carter on September 1st, 2009

I was at a school recently and a student asked me what I was most proud about achieving as an MP.

I thought about this and decided that actions taken in my role as Conservation Minister between 2002 and 2007 were what I most wanted to be remembered for.

Just after the 2008 election, Michael Cullen sent me a note which commented on how much land I had been responsible for adding to the conservation estate in NZ. I was over the moon about his generous gesture and remembered acquisitions like Kaikoura Island in the Hauraki Gulf and Molesworth Station in the South Island.  Altogether I added, with Cabinet’s support, 360,000 hectares of land to the conservation estate.  This land will be owned by Kiwis long after I am gone and forgotten.

I also remembered those memorable battles around the creation of new marine reserves during those five years.  Some of them really heated!  I can proudly say that of New Zealand’s 33 marine reserves 17 were created, and more than half a million hectares of beach or ocean were protected, in the 5 years I was Conservation Minister.

Our natural environment is one of the most important things that define us as Kiwis.  The DOC estate – some 30% of New Zealand’s land area – not only brings millions of tourists to this country, but also ensures that all Kiwis have access to quality outdoor pursuits, and that we are world leaders in protecting our unique biodiversity.

National’s contribution to future generations, and the preservation of our unique landscapes and biodiversity, marine and terrestrial, has in eight short months seen the end of marine reserve applications, the audit of the whole DOC estate for mining, and the repeal of Labour’s rules against subdividing our unique lake-frontages in the South Island high country.

So much for Mr Key and the National Party being ambitious for New Zealand!  I guess they’re being ambitious for the fishing industry, the mining industry, and those 300 families that occupy vast areas of Crown lands in the South Island high country!

If you want to learn more the work I did as Conservation Minister, visit my newsletters archive

Note from Michael Cullen

Note from Michael Cullen


Remembering Ted Kennedy

Posted by Chris Carter on August 27th, 2009

The Labour team have been really saddened by the death of US Senator Edward “Ted” Kennedy overnight.

I think Edward Kennedy will be remembered not just as a part of a progressive political dynasty, but also as an icon of liberal democratic politics the world over. Of course he will always be recalled fondly for his work with the Special Olympics movement, and by those who fight for better health care for the vulnerable.

Edward Kenney believed strongly in Government’s ability to help people improve their lives. I think that’s a vision shared by Labour, and by many readers and contributors to this blog.


Chris Carter – out and about!

Posted by Chris Carter on August 6th, 2009

There’s been a lot of talk about me not fronting up re MP’s expenses.

I’ve never been reluctant to front up on hard issues; from my sexuality, to declining consent for the Whangamata Marina.

Hey, the Labour Caucus made the decision that no-one comments except Trevor, Whips and the Leadership. I’m loyal and – hard as it’s been to resist persistent baiting from journalists to “stop hiding” – I’ve been a loyal team player and remained silent.

If anyone is really interested to know about why my transport costs as Minister of Education and Ethnic Affairs in 2008 were higher than some other Ministers they can visit my website. There you can see the names of some of the more than 300 schools and ECEs I visited as Minister of Education, and some of the more than 200 events I attended as Minister of Ethnic Affairs. I once went to eight Ethnic festivals in Auckland on one Saturday!

You can also read a selection of my Education newsletters, and my Ethnic Affairs newsletters from that period, to learn about the events.

Journalists were told that last year I went on eight international trips. Shock horror! Of course it’s not much fun visiting a country for two days, with back to back meetings and speeches – especially with flight times sometimes as long as 17 hours!

These same journalists seem to forget that, as Education Minister, part of my job was to help foster the flow of international students – a business currently worth $2.3 billion dollars each year, and our fifth largest export industry! Never let facts stand in the way of a good story, journalists!

Not one cent went into my pocket, my partner’s pocket, or my family trust account.

I stand by my record as an active, and I hope hardworking, Government minister.