Red Alert

Archive for the ‘national’ Category

Very poor optics Mr Joyce

Posted by Grant Robertson on March 15th, 2010

It has not been the best week for Steven Joyce. Both his pronouncements on limiting access to student loans and reviewing the Super Gold card have seen him run an issue up the flagpole only to have to run it down again in very short order.

It seems that it all got the better of him on a visit to New Plymouth on Friday. The Taranaki Daily News has reported some very odd behaviour at the official opening of the Bell Block By-Pass. It sounds like a big local event with New Plymouth Mayor Peter Tennant in attendance along with former MP and Regional Councillor Roger Maxwell. The Daily News reports

But Mr Tennent was not long into his speech when Mr Joyce’s press secretary approached the minister and handed him a note. Mr Joyce then continually texted on his cellphone while Mr Tennent, then Mr Maxwell, spoke. And then, when it was the turn of New Zealand Transport Agency regional director Jenny Chetwynd to speak, Mr Joyce left his seat and walked behind a nearby bush so he could talk on his phone.

Apparently when the National cabinet are discussing their plans Mr Joyce is the first to raise the “optics” of a situation, ie how it will look to the public. I would say that texting at a public event is not good optics. Hiding behind a bush is also not good optics.

He was still behind the bush when all the speeches had finished, which forced organisers to postpone a ribbon-cutting ceremony for several minutes. When Mr Joyce wandered back out into the open, the remainder of the official opening continued without any further delays. After ceremonially cutting a ribbon and declaring the bypass open, he was then taken for a drive down the new section of highway in a big truck driven by New Plymouth MP Jonathan Young – and even then he was texting during most of his time in the cabin.

For the record, delaying a ribbon cutting ceremony because you are behind a bush talking on your cellphone is really poor optics, not to mention just plain discourteous. I am not sure about the optics of texting when Jonathan Young is driving “a big truck”, but it probably pays to keep half an eye on the road!

Now all of this took place on Friday. What was happening on Friday? Ah yes. That was just about the point that the review of the SuperGold card was turning into a rapidly descending flag. It would be fascinating to know who was on the other end of the phone, but I am guessing his first name was probably John.


Epsom blue?

Posted by Trevor Mallard on March 14th, 2010

In a sign that the Nats have decided to rerun the worthless approach I’m told Jackie Blue is being lined up as the Nat candidate in Epsom.

Green light Rodney and one or two mates. Act list process will be fascinating.


Chicken shanks

Posted by Trevor Mallard on March 10th, 2010

Shanks Poll - National Standards

Within ten minutes of the Red Alert post on her poll show 85% opposed Tolley’s lowering of standards going up Katrina Shanks took it down and even deleted it from her archives.

Talk about dishonest. Goebbels would be proud of her attempt to rewrite history.

We are working to get a screen shot of the survey result.


So this is smile and wave’s secret plan to stop illegal whaling

Posted by Trevor Mallard on March 8th, 2010

Remember Key had a secret plan to end illegal whaling by Japan which he was going to check out with Clinton when she was to visit here.

It is now out for us all to see.

He wants to legalise it.

But then again the National Party has a history of selling out on widely shared kiwi principles. I had hoped we had got to the point where our Prime Minister never genuflected  kowtowed to overseas interests.

Shame on you John Key.


Time to plead guilty bill

Posted by Trevor Mallard on March 8th, 2010

Yet another inquiry into the Brash email leaks doesn’t find quite enough evidence to name the Deputy Prime Minister.


Lions on the hustings – chickens under pressure

Posted by Trevor Mallard on March 5th, 2010

The Dompost reports that Key, Hide and Garrett weren’t available to make substantive comment on Garrett’s plan  to sterilise people.

Smile and wave wouldn’t rule it out. Hide hid. Spokesperson made non comment. And big brave Garrett may have left the country again.

What a dopey idea – have three or four kids, decide you want a vasectomy and to get one free you have to beat up one of the kids.

But both smile and wave and jeckyl and hide wanted the focus group results before they were prepared to put their opinions into the public arena. Talk about being gutless wonders.


Another key promise broken – wage gap with aussie to blow out

Posted by Trevor Mallard on March 1st, 2010

A Grant Thornton survey of employers in NZ and Australia reported in the Herald, has resulted in their prediction that the wage gap is set to increase.

They are predicting the brain drain to turn into a full flowing torrent.

Not really surprising. From unemployment being 4.2% in both countries in 2008 we now have 7.3% and going up and they have 5.3% and going down.

And what was the difference. The Aussie government took positive counter measures which minimised the employment flow on from the recession while John Key sat on his hands, ran a talk fest, and in fact made the situation worse with cuts.

I’m not sure whether Key knows what he is doing and is deeply cycnical, or doesn’t know what he is doing.


Whose going into Cabinet? II

Posted by Trevor Mallard on February 28th, 2010

Seems to be firming up on Nathan Guy.

Some discussion of Amy Adams getting the out of Cabinet role. Key getting worried about performance of most of the women ministers.


Why did I buy a new mountain bike?

Posted by Trevor Mallard on February 28th, 2010

Because I thought we would have a cycleway. But according to the Herald not a metre has been built since John Key announced it a year ago.

And btw how much fibre has gone in as a result of Joyce’s work?


So was the urgency worth it Gerry

Posted by Trevor Mallard on February 26th, 2010

Sometimes you can get too smart for your own good. Gerry Brownlee did this week. He put far too much in an urgency motion. He was offered a deal that included questions. He has now revealed that he wanted at least one Select Committee to sit at Parliament by leave at the the time the house was sitting.

Labour said no. Gerry lost his cool rejected the deal and ended up getting much much less through than he would have otherwise.

He found out that if the opposition decides to go into a no co-operation phase hours can be spent with no progress whatsoever.

He also found out that Christopher Finlayson (no QC) notwithstanding his FIGJAM approach doesn’t have the brains to stand and take a call even when he has his instructions wrtitten down for him.

Hope that Brownlee enjoys explaining to the next Cabinet and caucus what happened and that Hone Carter can give advice as what to do next time.


So who is going into Cabinet

Posted by Trevor Mallard on February 25th, 2010

Intense discussion opposite between Tremain and Foss – the Hawkes Bay rivals for Heatley’s job.

Favourite possibly Nathan Guy but after today’s repeat of yesterdays procedural shambles I will renew my call for Key to bring Hone Carter into cabinet and make him leader of the House.


Video: John Key on GST

Posted by Chris Hipkins on February 24th, 2010


Tax expectations

Posted by Trevor Mallard on February 22nd, 2010

Small not too focused group, majority from the right,  but not involved in politics, tongues loosened had a discussion on their expectations of tax changes. I listened.

No real interest in threshold changes. Their consensus was while they wanted more, but thought English and Key didn’t have it in them, the budget in May will drop the top rate to 30c (from 38) the middle income rate to 25c (33) and the under $48k rate to 15c (21). A couple of people thought that Key would phase the top rate change in over two years to make him look less personally greedy. But that it would be announced this May.

Would make for some interesting modelling.


The people smile and wave is relying on

Posted by Trevor Mallard on February 22nd, 2010

The government has two very big issues running at the moment. GST (in the context of the budget) and National’s standards in primary education.

But the Ministers leading these areas are the two most damaged Ministers in the government.

Since his housing rorts have been exposed English has had very little credibility when is comes to fiscal prudence. His problem has been both actual and more importantly perception. Even natural allies are asking whether the change will come in the short term (Power) or later (Joyce).

And while those who work closely with her are mainly being polite the degree of exasperation with Anne Tolley is growing by the week. In this case it is pretty simply a Minister who can’t cope with the job. While that was most obvious in the tertiary area where she was removed following approaches to Key from within the sector it is increasingly clear that she can’t get her head around her own flagship standards policy. Tolley might have made a good junior Minister but she just doesn’t have the grunt to cope with the front bench and the education portfolio.

So should Labour be calling for their resignation. Probably not. Ministers who are seen to be performing poorly are like rust – it sometimes takes a long time to surface but eventually will wreck the whole machine.

I say leave them in place – for now.


What happened to smile and wave saving the whales

Posted by Trevor Mallard on February 21st, 2010

Hearing Rudd reminded me that smile and wave had a  plan to stop Japanese whaling.

We are still waiting John. You are beginning to look silly.


Whanau Ora another issue

Posted by Trevor Mallard on February 20th, 2010

Most of the focus on Whanau Ora has been on ethnicity of those who will  run and and use Whanau Ora.

Isn’t the bigger issue going to be those who can’t get access to their current provider (eg doctor), or are charged more because a contract has been cut to fund Tariana’s family’s programme.


Dompost gets it

Posted by Trevor Mallard on February 16th, 2010

tom scott cartoon

For those of you who don’t see Dompost – this is pretty good.


Uranium on Key’s breath – trade with Iran increasing?

Posted by Trevor Mallard on February 15th, 2010

The very idea you can own uranium shares as you open our national parks to mining and believe you can get away with it.

I’m sure it is an indication of an absence of understanding of the basic ethics necessary as a decisionmaker. Trying to make Double Dipton look good?

Makes one wonder what else there is in those see through blind trusts.

And which MFAT reports he has seen without declaring conflicts.

TVNZ story here.


Key f**ked – HoS

Posted by Trevor Mallard on February 14th, 2010

Tags:
Filed under: GST, humour, national

Will Key ever answer questions?

Posted by Chris Hipkins on February 9th, 2010

Parliament resumes today after the summer recess. Hopefully that will prompt John Key to finally stump up with answers to the Written Parliamentary Questions I put to him before Christmas. I asked him 67 questions late last year. In all cases he said he couldn’t give me an answer within the 6 days required by the written questions system, but he assured me I’d get the information as soon as possible.

It’s now 8 weeks since I asked the questions, but alas no answers have arrived. The questions were legitimate questions asking him to account for the spending of his ministers at a time when they were telling us all to tighten our belts.

We saw last year that National Ministers do not practice what they preach on fiscal responsibility and the public deserves to know what they are spending, e.g. the Bill English rort to finance his family home and the last minute changes to let ministers use self-drive cars meant to help them serve their electorates in Wellington.

Labour answered these types of questions when asked by a National Opposition so what is Key hiding?

Here is a quick summary of the topics that I asked Key about:

  • Pay rises for staff working in Ministerial offices (remember other public servants have a wage freeze)
  • Use of VIP cars during National’s first year in office
  • Refurbishment costs for ministerial offices
  • Spending on gifts, beer, wine and spirits by ministers
  • Purchase of self-drive vehicles and related issues
  • Issues relating to Key’s changes to ministerial housing allowances

John Key talks a lot about transparency and accountability but it is all talk. The reality is neither he nor his ministers think that the rules that apply to others apply to them. Key’s ongoing refusal to answer basic written parliamentary questions just proves that.