Red Alert

Archive for the ‘Pay Equity’ Category

Dumb and dumber

Posted by Darien Fenton on October 23rd, 2009

Does John Key realise how much he has annoyed both teachers and school support staff with his comments to the CTU conference this week that teachers should trade off their own pay rises to fund pay increases for low paid school support staff?

I’ve been doing the rounds of North Shore schools today and staff – teachers and support staff – are not impressed. They say his comments are divisive and stupid. Teachers and support staff work together to make the school community function well and there’s no way they will buy into this kind of divide and rule tactic.

John Key’s comments were dumb politics. But what’s even dumber is the PM’s ignorance about how teachers and support staff are funded and how their employment agreements are bargained.

Teachers are centrally funded by the Ministry of Education, and their negotiations are separate to those of school support staff. School support staff are funded out of school’s operations budgets.

So even if the teachers were to forgo pay increases (and that couldn’t happen until next year when bargaining is due), there’s no guarantee that would translate into increased ops grants to pay school support staff more.


Melissa and bill

Posted by Trevor Mallard on October 13th, 2009

What is it with these Nats. Years of false declarations and they think an offer to pay back part of the money (Bill) and all of it (Melissa) means  they can expect to be forgiven. And no doubt they are going to tell us again today what careful custodians they are of the public purse. They are just not credible.

Now is when we see if Key has backbone. It is a big test for him.


NZ Bus stupid

Posted by Trevor Mallard on October 10th, 2009

The Herald reports that NZ Bus have rejected an offer from locked out drivers to drive school buses without pay when term starts on Monday.

Don’t know who is giving NZ Bus PR advice but they have made a big mistake here. If there are big traffic jams or one kid goes missing while walking home the bosses will cop the blame.

And they will cause a pile of unnecessary parental anxiety and time wasting even if there are no direct problems.

Just don’t understand why they didn’t say yes. Locking out very low paid drivers for having the cheek to do their jobs according to the rules is bad enough but this is certainly a very bad look.


Bill’s treatment of taxpayers

Posted by Trevor Mallard on October 9th, 2009

Following the Herald cartoon below this YouTube video adds a bit more to Bill’s approach:


A decade old bill I

Posted by Trevor Mallard on October 9th, 2009

Just to show that we haven’t forgotten thought would share a few of the gems that haven’t made it to the net previously.

booby


Transtasman on English Succession

Posted by Trevor Mallard on October 8th, 2009

Steven Joyce looks to be stand-out candidate. Of course Joyce is a list MP, so even if he is regarded as Key’s right-hand man, he mightn’t be in the running for deputy, …….

Trans-Tasman’s money is on Simon Power.

And here is what I said last week.

But I’m not sure what they mean by being a list MP. Could be an advantage especially if you don’t feel an obligation to go back to your primary place of residence in Dipton every week.


English – corruption

Posted by Trevor Mallard on October 3rd, 2009

Friday, 25 August 2006, 4:52 pm
Column: New Zealand National Party
Plain English – Thoughts from your MP for Clutha/Southland

There is No Shame

“The New Zealand public will ultimately decide the standards of public probity in politics. If they let [... get] away with … rort, then standards of transparency and honesty will drop across the board. … New Zealand politics stays clean because all politicians have presumed the public don’t tolerate corruption, and because politicians do not want the shame of being seen as anything but squeaky clean – until now that is. … believe that … can tough it out, that if … doesn’t admit any wrongdoing, the media will eventually drop it, and the public don’t really care. … doesn’t appear to believe the idea than any rules of public probity should get in the way of [the party's] interests.”

Thanks to Jack McDonald commenting on the Standard.

Doesn’t need much elaboration.


Good luck Bill

Posted by Trevor Mallard on October 2nd, 2009

The government website reports:-

Finance Minister Bill English leaves for Hong Kong and London this Sunday to raise New Zealand’s profile with investors and business groups, and to share ideas about the next steps in economic recovery.

On behalf of lots of Kiwis I wish Bill good luck and hope that his domestic credibility problems don’t cause the sort of questioning that flows through into rate margins on Crown borrowing. We can’t afford it.


English docs the A-G will consider IV – who could I possibly be?

Posted by Trevor Mallard on September 30th, 2009

While this note is headed English power details, it goes to the request for extra cleaning, the most important question is whose name was deleted from the email?

Despite being sent on a Friday it shows no sign of coming from Dipton.

No prize for this one.


English docs the A-G will consider III – so who runs the trust

Posted by Trevor Mallard on September 29th, 2009

And now for number three in the series. More on the cleaning issue. Claim via Bill. But I thought Bill didn’t see the bills because Bill had no interest in the trust. These documents keep giving answers but even more questions. One important question is “Why did such an experienced politician do this?”


Bill folding?

Posted by Trevor Mallard on September 28th, 2009

So now English accepts he has lived in Wellington since the last election. That leaves questions the first set of which are :-

  1. Where did he live for the 10 – 15 years before that?
  2. Why did he try a trust lease device to attempt to collect even more than he had been?
  3. How can he repay money from a trust that he has no interest in?
  4. Was/is the trust a sham?
  5. What did he tell John Key that caused Key to back him when his position was clearly unsustainable?
  6. Given 1 -5 above will he ever have the credibility necessary to tell Kiwis to tighten their belts?

English docs the A-G will consider II – the lease device

Posted by Trevor Mallard on September 28th, 2009

The second of the documents. It includes the rental agreement which is a device to lease the Karori house from the reorganised trust to Ministerial Services. Ministerial Services appears to have paid for a rental appraisal.  Again not a knock out blow – but a picture is developing. And the real question “Why did Bill do it?” –  is still very hard to answer.


English docs the A-G will consider I – pay the money here.

Posted by Trevor Mallard on September 27th, 2009

I intend to provide links to a series of the English housing documents. On their own the don’t amount to knock out victories but they sure build a picture. The first  shows that the trust was not arms length from English in that he was instructing Ministerial Services on mattters as detailed as to which account to pay money. More tomorrow.


English has to admit Dipton’s dipped out

Posted by Trevor Mallard on September 26th, 2009

This is this weeks political column from the Herald.  I don’t think it needs any elaboration.

John Armstrong: English has to admit Dipton’s dipped out

The time has come for Bill “Double Dipton” English to end the charade.

It has been apparent for a while that it is no longer tenable for him to stipulate his primary place of residence as being in his Clutha-Southland electorate when his real home has long been in Wellington.

It is not just a matter of putting things right to satisfy the Cabinet Manual’s requirement that ministers “behave in a way that upholds, and is seen to uphold, the highest ethical standards”.

His highly questionable claim to be an out-of-Wellington MP – a status which made him eligible for an accommodation allowance while in Opposition and which entitles him to taxpayer-funded ministerial accommodation now he is in Government – has become unsustainable in purely political terms.

(more…)


Here are the links

Posted by Trevor Mallard on September 25th, 2009

First to the Auditor Generals 2001 report. Part 2, starting page 56 covers the Wellington Allowance issue and page 61 has their take on what needs to be considered to define primary residence.

Second the form MPs fill in to establish their primary place of residence.

Hope these help people follow the Auditor General story.


Corruption bill speech

Posted by Trevor Mallard on September 25th, 2009

Thanks to all the kind emails and calls re Labour’s performance in the House on the money laundering and remuneration authority legislation last night. Our team was on fire. Here is 5min that highlights the nats problem.


A-G prelim look at English – breaking news

Posted by Trevor Mallard on September 25th, 2009

Herald has broken the story that has been discussed round the buildings. Here it is:

Friday Sep 25, 2009
By Patrick Gower

The Office of the Auditor-General has announced it will make “preliminary enquiries” into whether Deputy Prime Minister Bill English was right to claim a taxpayer-funded accommodation allowance.

A spokeswoman for the office told nzherald.co.nz they would begin gathering “background information” to decided whether to a full inquiry was warranted.

It follows a complaint from Progressives MP Jim Anderton about the out-of-town accommodation costs Mr English has been claiming.

Mr English is MP for Clutha Southland and while his wife is a GP in Wellington and his children go to school there, it is officially his secondary residence and he is able to claim accommodation costs as an out-of-town MP.

Mr Anderton asked the Auditor-General for an investigation into whether Wellington is actually Mr English’s primary residence.

A spokeswoman the office said: “We have not yet decided whether to inquire into this matter, but see it as appropriate for this Office to make some preliminary enquiries to gather background information.

“Once we have had an opportunity to consider that information we will decide whether any further action by this Office, such as beginning a formal inquiry, is warranted.”

The spokeswoman said a decision on whether to undertake a full inquiry was expected in about two weeks time.


House tactics – double dippers together

Posted by Trevor Mallard on September 25th, 2009

When will the Nats learn that putting Pesata Sam Lotu-iiga (the person yet to resign as an Auckland City Councillor) up to ask Bill English (resident of Dipton -yeah right) questions on fiscal prudence should stop.

Once was a mistake, twice was silly, three times inept and four unbelievable.


House tactics – Wiremu Pakeha missing

Posted by Trevor Mallard on September 24th, 2009

So we have had urgency for each week of the current session.

Last night the house finished four hours early because the government had run out of business.

And now we are back in urgency doing the ETS.

But we are also doing the Remuneration Authority legislation, the policy for which was announced months ago, and the Money Laundering legislation which as been around forever. Both these could have been done on Tuesday if Brownlee got his act together.

Trying to work out why they are doing these two. Maybe it is because Bill English is away. Possibly trying to see if he remembers the way back to Dipton.


15,808 stand up for Fairness @ Work

Posted by Sue Moroney on September 22nd, 2009

pay-equity-challenge-005Today my petition was tabled in Parliament calling on the Government to reinstate two pay equity investigations it axed in March for school support staff and social workers; to implement the findings of 65 previously completed pay equity investigations and to develop a strategy to eliminate the 12% gender pay gap.

15,808 other decent New Zealanders joined me by signing the petition. Thousands of others would have signed it if they had the opportunity to.

On Friday, I hosted an event at Parliament to celebrate the official launch of the “Pay Equity Challenge” – a coalition of 26 NZ organisations dedicated to campaigning around this issue.

I hope the Government is listening. If they were, then Tony Ryall would be made to reinstate the pay equity investigations he axed and Kate Wilkinson would re-establish the Pay and Employment Equity Unit she closed down in May. Minister of Women’s Affairs Pansy Wong should have stopped her colleagues from carrying out both of these acts against hard-working New Zealand women and their families.

On Saturday, New Zealand celebrated 116 years since women got the right to vote. Unfortunately, this National Government is taking us backward on the gender pay gap issue and family incomes are being affected as a result.

(The photo above is of your’s truly speaking at the Pay Equi-Tea event. As well as being in period costume, the Pay Equity Challengers had baked a cake – but 12% was missing!)