Red Alert

Archive for the ‘civil liberties’ Category

Dillon on Drug Cheat Cropp

Posted by Trevor Mallard on December 27th, 2009

Mike Dillon racing editor of the Herald on Sunday has published book based on Lisa Cropp’s drug use.

As Dillon says of methamphetamine:-

It’s perfect for jockeys – it creates massive doses of energy, suppresses appetite and can eliminate itself from a detection zone in as little as 22 hours, compared with a minimum of 20 days for cannabis.

Dillon provides a good timeline in the main article which shows how Cropp delayed justice for years, won races worth millions of dollars and broke the NZ record for the most winners as she lost case after case all the way to the Supreme Court.

The danger of driving around the country from meeting to meeting and then riding half ton horses at great speed with about twenty others while on meth is way beyond what is acceptable.

Dillon’s piece makes it clear that the racing authorities and journalists were aware of Cropp’s behaviour over a long period and did not have a way of stopping her.

It does raise the question of whether that type of evidence should be available for prosecution for drug use and/or driving offences as well.


Should Red Alert out ministerial staff who make comments

Posted by Trevor Mallard on December 12th, 2009

I recently outed someone who commented on Red Alert on an issue they were very close to but used a pseudonym. Admin thought it was unusual. Clare told me she wanted to talk about it. Grant was more direct. I was admonished.

But now an interesting issue has arisen.

Ministerial staffers are commenting on Red Alert from the Beehive - during normal working hours – using pseudonyms.

We have always known they monitor our blog. Several Ministers read it daily as well.

But is it really part of their job to comment? And if it is should they be transparent as we are when we post here and comment on other blogs.

And if they aren’t should we out them?

Interesting issue – causing debate in our team. We would welcome your views.


Tumeke on pay the bill ad for 7

Posted by Trevor Mallard on October 26th, 2009

Fair amount of email traffic on this and I’m sure it will be taken up but in the interim couldn’t  put it much  better than Bomber on Tumeke.


Nats vote against civil liberties, as usual

Posted by Charles Chauvel on October 15th, 2009

Parliament is in the process of passing the Criminal Investigations (Bodily Samples) Amendment Bill. It would allow the Police to take DNA samples when they arrest anyone.

I can see the possibilities for better crime prevention in this proposal. But I’m troubled by the lack of any checks and balances in the Bill. A similar English law was set aside by the European Cout of Human Rights on that ground, and the Attorney-General has certified that the NZ Bill breaches the NZ Bill of Rights Act.

I put an amendment up tonight, further to a Labour caucus resolution, that would have required the Police to get a warrant before taking DNA. I reasoned that if they need a warrant to search a building they should need one to apply literal physical compulsion to a person. They don’t have problems finding a JP to grant these warrants so I don’t think getting one to take a DNA sample would be an administrative problem. And we’d have Bill of Rights compliant legislation.

The Greens, Progressives and Maori Party voted with Labour for the amendment. Peter Dunne voted against. So did ACT (so much for being “the liberal party”). And so did the Nats, without really bothering to say why. I guess they think it will play well out in talkbackland.

The Nats adjourned the House before we got to my other amendment – a requirement that Parliament review the operation of the law within 5 years. But it looks like they’ll vote that one down too when we get to it next week. I hope I can be in the House for it. But instead I’ll probably be in the Finance and Expenditure Committee, working through what is becoming pretty much a universally-condemned Emissions Trading Amendment Bill. Sigh.

Not a good day for civil liberties.