Red Alert

Author Archive

Carter – statement on ministerial expenses

Posted by Chris Carter on June 10th, 2010

I have carefully checked, and re-checked, the large quantity of documents given to me yesterday covering the years 2003 to 2008, when I served in various ministerial roles including Conservation, Local Government, Building and Housing, Building Issues, Ethnic Affairs, Housing and Education.

I have identified the following items which may have been outside existing spending rules. These costs were incurred either by me, or my staff – but I take full responsibility for all of them.

• 18 June 2003
Staff-member watching movie in hotel, Berlin. No record of reimbursement by staff-member.
EUR 11.50 = NZD 23.15 (as at 18 June 2003 conversion rate)

• 25 February 2004
Flowers for a colleague on ministerial resignation, from office staff and MP. No record of reimbursement.
NZD 58.00

• 8 March 2004
Flowers for partner’s birthday, sent by SPS. Notation says staff contributed, but there are no receipts.
NZD 80.00

• 31 December 2006
Movie in hotel, Washington, USA
USD 17.97 = NZD 25.49 (as at 31 December 2006 conversion rate)

• 9 April 2008
Staff-member at hotel spa, China. No record of reimbursement by staff-member.
RMB (China) 360.00 = 64.52 (as at 31 December 2006 conversion rate)

A cheque for NZD 251.16 will be sent today to the Department of Internal Affairs (Ministerial Services) to cover this full amount.

My ministerial office was a very busy place. My staff were competent, hard working and committed to public service. Small mistakes were perhaps inevitable, but never excusable.


Anti-whaling protest at Parliament

Posted by Chris Carter on June 2nd, 2010

A staunch group of conservation activists came to Parliament today to present their petition opposing any moves to restart commercial whaling.

More than 50,000 Kiwis signed the petition in only a month and a half!

Petition presentation at Parliament, 2 June 2010

Thanks for WSPA, Greenpeace, Project Jonah, Forest and Bird, and the Whale and Dolphin Conservation Society for keeping pressure on the National-Act Government over this important issue. We must not let John Key allow commercial whaling.

It’s a shame that Foreign Minister Murray McCully didn’t have the courtesy to meet the environmentalists or have the guts to collect the petition in person.

Petition presentation at Parliament, 2 June 2010


Israeli actions condemned

Posted by Chris Carter on June 1st, 2010

Israel’s killing of at least 19 people in international waters, when it intervened to stop the flotilla which was seeking to take humanitarian aid supplies to Gaza, is being condemned by the New Zealand Labour Party and many other political parties and governments around the world. The presence of a New Zealander on one of the seized ships gives us a personal connection to this tragedy.

This brutal response by Israel will do little to improve that country’s already tarnished image as it continues to blockade the 1.5 million Palestinians living in the Gaza Stip. Such actions cannot help to lead to a lasting and fair solution of the complex issues involving Israel and the Palestinians.

Read Labour Leader Phil Goff’s statement on the situation here.


Australia’s Environment Minister on Key’s whaling plans

Posted by Chris Carter on April 2nd, 2010

Australia’s Environment Minister, Peter Garrett, talking about John Key’s grand initative to end the global moratorium on commercial whaling:

“I am alarmed and very concerned that NZ would support a proposal that is flawed and represents a huge compromise to pro-whaling nations….Australia cannot support the compromise package now being discussed in the IWC.”

Labour doesn’t support Key’s plans for whaling either. Click here for more.


Key’s whaling plans confirmed

Posted by Chris Carter on April 1st, 2010

Australian media have confirmed that John Key’s National Party Government is trying to lift the international moratorium against whaling.

Meanwhile the Australian Government have said again that they reject the notion that killing some whales will save others.

http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2010/04/01/2862436.htm

The Japanese whale slaughter industry will be delighted by the confirmation of John Key’s plans.


McCully’s temper tantrum

Posted by Chris Carter on March 31st, 2010

I received a call today informing me that this morning’s 10am MFAT briefing on John Key’s confusing whaling policy, organised by Foreign Minister McCully for the Opposition and to be presented by NZ’s International Whaling Commission representative Sir Geoffrey Palmer, has been cancelled. The reason given – the Minister was so “upset” with my posting of yesterday. In that posting I revealed from undisclosed sources in DOC and MFAT that the Government was about to quietly dump the proposal to promote a return to limited commercial whaling to appease the Japanese because traditional allies at the IWC didn’t support it and neither did a majority of the NZ public. I guess McCully’s little hissy fit this morning confirms the information. This whole shambles around NZ’s position on whaling smacks of diplomatic amateurism and will have harmed our 100% Pure international reputation. This is one flip-flop Labour would agree with. We don’t want any commercial whaling.


A whale of a diplomatic mess

Posted by Chris Carter on March 30th, 2010

The Prime Minister’s habit of announcing policy off the cuff has seen some New Zealand diplomats start some not-entirely-diplomatic whispers.

The scuttlebutt inside both MFAT and DOC has been that John Key has now doubly-humiliated his officials with his muddled proposal to restart commercial whaling.

To recap: In January the Prime Minister was looking forward to a visit from the US Secretary of State. He blithely announced a grand new initiative to stop Japanese whaling in the Southern Ocean – the details of which he’d fully reveal only once the Secretary was on the ground and our Press Gallery were paying maximum attention.

Concerned that the PM was demonstrating no real understanding of the polarised politics of whaling, officials rushed to ask Key what his proposal was. After a bit of too-ing and fro-ing the policy, apparently, Mr Key struck on was legalising limited commercial whaling. Essentially killing the endangered whales as a sop to the Japanese whaling industry might paradoxically save the whales.

Lo and behold our representative to the International Whaling Commission, Sir Geoffrey Palmer, was dispatched to Florida to make Key’s vision a reality. I can only imagine how Sir Geoffrey must have felt; a long-time champion of whale conservation, respected Chair of the IWC, and former Labour Prime Minister to boot, he now had the unenviable task of selling a pro-whaling message on behalf of Key’s National Government!

I found out about the inside story almost immediately. Our diplomats knew they were breaking basic principles of diplomacy (and they knew their negotiating partners knew it too); the NZ side was conceding to the vested commercial interests of Japan’s whaling industry without any concrete promise of reciprocal concessions whatsoever. The many Conservation NGO organisations with branches in New Zealand phoned me from Florida as the farce was unfolding.

(more…)


The economic value of keeping our Conservation Estate protected

Posted by Chris Carter on March 23rd, 2010

The Conservation Estate – 33% of New Zealand’s land area, owned by all Kiwis and managed by the Department of Conservation (DOC) on our behalf – is well recognised as important for biodiversity and landscape protection.

What is less well known is its economic value to our economy.

When I served as Conservation Minister (2002 – 2007) I commissioned a series of economic impact studies to look at how the DOC estate contributes to regional economic development. click here [PDF link] to read the study report.

This material is particularly relevant to the debate around mining in Conservation areas and the National-Act Government’s proposed changes to those regulations.


2,000 and counting – Save the Whales!

Posted by Chris Carter on March 12th, 2010

The Labour Party’s online petition opposing John Key’s apparent plans to resume commercial whaling has been signed by more than 2,000 people in less than 48 hours.

If you don’t think NZ should be a pro-whaling nation please send John Key a strong message and sign the petition. You can do it here on Red Alert by clicking this link.

Alternatively, sign the petition on my website at carter.org.nz/savethewhales.

Thanks for your support.


More than 1,000 people say No Commercial Whaling!

Posted by Chris Carter on March 11th, 2010

Thank to your help with Labour’s online petition for people who oppose the resumption of commercial whaling. The petition has been signed by more than one thousand people in less than 24 hours.

The vast majority of signatories are Kiwis. But a few people overseas have signed up – even people from countries which allow whaling.

It’s becoming clear that John Key’s moves to restart commercial whaling are seriously damaging New Zealand’s international image. I received this posting on my website from Kane Slater, a Canadian:

  1. Kane Slater Said,My trip to NZ has now been cancelled. I’ll spend my Canadian dollars in Australia.

Mr Key is supposedly the Tourism Minister as well as our Prime Minister. What will he say to our whale watching and conservation tourism operators in Kaikoura and around New Zealand?

If you don’t think NZ should be a pro-whaling nation please send John Key a strong message and sign the petition today. You can do it here on Red Alert by clicking this link.

Alternatively, sign the petition on my website at carter.org.nz/savethewhales.


Mr Key, we don’t want commerical whaling!

Posted by Chris Carter on March 10th, 2010

Thank you very much to those of you who have signed my anti-whaling petition today!

John Key seems to have joined New Zealand up to the group of pro-commercial whaling nations. In a little over a year the National-Act Government has turned our country from being a world leader in marine mammal conservation into an advocate for the resumption of commercial whaling.

The Labour Party opposes whaling. For more information click here.

If you haven’t signed the petition then please help send a strong message to John Key and Foreign Minister Murray McCully that New Zealanders expect our Government to stand up for endangered species. Sign the petition now:

Number of people who have already signed the petition:


St Kitts and Nevis election report

Posted by Chris Carter on February 19th, 2010

As reported earlier the Commonwealth Secretary General Kamalesh Sharma asked me to lead a Commonwealth election observer team to monitor the general election in St Kitts and Nevis on 25 January 2010. I was honoured to be approached for this mission and was happy to donate 2 weeks of my summer break to assist.

Other team members included Krishnan Srinivasan, the former head of India’s Foreign Ministry and Lorna Simon, the Supervisor of Elections for Antigua and Barbuda.

I have had some previous experience in the role of election monitoring. I was a member of the Commonwealth Team that monitored South Africa’s first multiracial election in 1994, was an official observer in the US Presidential election in 2000, and led the large New Zealand election team which monitored the Solomon Islands’ election in 2002.

You can now access our full report on the St Kitts and Nevis general election (712kb).

Note: You may require Adobe Reader software to be installed on your computer in order to open the file linked to this page. You can download a free version of Adobe Reader at the Adobe website.


Fairness and Mr Farrar

Posted by Chris Carter on February 12th, 2010

Some of you may have read David Farrar’s post today.

I have never bothered replying to the right wing spin on David’s blog before, but this story is too ridiculous to let slide.

At 11.03am I responded to David, however so far he is refusing to post what I have said. From 11.23am several posters’ comments have gone online, so I am assuming David doesn’t intend to give me a right of reply.

I hope in the spirit of fairness David will post my response on his blog so his readers can make up their own minds.

Here is what I posted at 11.03am:

David,

There’s nothing like a half-truth twisted to suit a certain political agenda.

Yes, I did catch the wrong ferry, and easily done because the departure of the Waiheke ferry had changed from its usual Pier 3 to Pier 1. Never having caught the ferry at night before I did not realise that this was where the night departure takes place.

It’s an absolute lie that I requested to be picked up by the Waiheke ferry at Devonport. I was happy to catch the ferry back to Auckland and jump on the later 11.45pm to Waiheke.

The lovely Fullers crew on the Devonport ferry however, realising I was in the wrong place, offered to contact the Waiheke crew.

I insisted this not happen because it wasn’t a big deal to head back to Auckland. But those lovely men and woman went ahead and did it independently of me and organised a pickup. That’s pretty great service from Fullers and I’ll be sending them a letter of thanks. They told me this sort of thing happens often at night because the Waiheke and Devonport ferries leave from the same place.

Apparently it added a just a few minutes to the Waiheke journey and I apologise to the other passengers for the inconvenience.

Enjoyed chatting to Michelle Boag and grateful to her friend who gave me a lift to my bach in Palm Beach.

David, I’ve never bothered replying to the right wing spin on your blog. But your claim that I threw my weight around to deliberately inconvenience passengers is just too outrageous to let pass.

I’m sure the crew on the Fullers Devonport ferry will be able to confirm everything I’ve said.

Regards,

Chris Carter.


TAXI FARE

Posted by Chris Carter on February 12th, 2010

Last night Lianne Dalziel and I shared a cab from Parliament to Wellington airport. Nice driver, Chinese migrant and keen to talk about politics.

He told us he voted National last time, but he and his wife are returning to Labour next time! Why? “ACC, growing unemployment and crime.”

Lianne asked him why he changed his vote in 2008 and he said he bought into the idea of ‘It’s time for a change.’ “Big mistake!” His words.

When I arrived in Auckland I asked my Punjabi migrant driver the same question, “Who was he doing to vote for at the next election?”

“Labour!” he said.

Actually he fessed up to always being a Labour voter, but said that many of his fellow Punjabi drivers had changed their vote in 2008, and now were going back to Labour. Again, ACC charges and disillusionment with the current Government.

I know that two taxi drivers is only a very small sample, but I would urge readers to question their driver when they’re next in a taxi to see where the political wind is blowing.

P.S. A message to Cameron Slater. Cameron, you seem to think that as Foreign Affairs Spokesperson I’m “silent” on international issues. I suggest you check my website at carter.org.nz to read some of my releases. My full report on the St Kitts and Nevis general election will be online soon.


St Kitts and Nevis election monitoring

Posted by Chris Carter on January 19th, 2010

I’m heading off to St Kitts and Nevis tonight to lead the international Commonwealth team monitoring their elections.

It’s a real privilege to have been asked to carry out this important work by Commonwealth Secretary General Kamalesh Sharma. I guess it shows how respected New Zealand is in the world! We are one of the oldest democracies on earth, but I think that decisions taken by successive Labour Governments – such as our nuclear free policy and more recently keeping New Zealanders safe and out of the Iraq War – have really raised our global profile as a fair player and a strong defender of human rights.

Many New Zealanders may not have heard a lot about the small Caribbean nation of St Kitts and Nevis. It’s a really beautiful island chain with very friendly people, which I know because I represented New Zealand as Conservation Minister during the International Whaling Commission meeting there in 2006. But the country has suffered from corruption and the results of the last election there were hotly disputed. You can read more about St Kitts and Nevis at the CIA World Factbook.

United Nations Development Programme officials have asked to brief me about recent issues in Caribbean democracy and development before I arrive in the capital Basseterre, which will be really useful. There are some parallels between island-nation development in the Caribbean and closer to home here in our Pacific region.

St Kitts and Nevis is only an hour’s flight from Haiti, so I’m going to be paying a lot of attention to how the small states in the region have been able to respond to the terrible earthquake there. Many readers will remember that last year Luamanuvao Winnie Laban and I boarded the first flight to Samoa immediately following their devastating earthquake. If you ever have to hold a mother as she cries for her missing baby, as I did in Samoa, you’ll probably become as passionate about improving global disaster relief as I am.

I’m really hoping the St Kitts and Nevis election will run smoothly and properly, and that the free and fair will of the people will be expressed in the outcome without my intervention. I’ll look to report back to Red Alert readers after the results are in.

I’m likely to be gone for just under three weeks. My flights are being covered by the Commonwealth and I’ll meet any miscellaneous expenses myself so New Zealand taxpayers won’t foot any of the bill.


Routeburn Track with Helen

Posted by Chris Carter on January 4th, 2010

Off to walk the Routeburn Track with Helen Clark and Peter Davis today. Really looking forward to the tramp and a chance to catch up with all Helen’s news!

Both Helen and I have served as Conservation Ministers and we both have a passion for the DOC estate. Let’s hope the Nats don’t wreck it with their “energy audit.”

chrishelen


On Samoa II

Posted by Chris Carter on October 6th, 2009

What a great posting from Winnie. I am so glad she agreed to go with me to Samoa. She was not only a wonderful travelling companion, but her understanding of the appropriate cultural approach and her Samoan language skills meant we could engage with those affected by this terrible natural disaster in the most sensitive ways. I see the usual suspects in the media have been making snide comments about Winnie and me going immediately to Samoa on the day the tsunami happened. I can only endorse Winnie’s words that every single person we met, Samoan or Kiwi, seemed genuinely delighted we came.

My own links with the Samoan community run deep. I was first elected as the Member of Parliament for Te Atatu in 1993. Almost 17% of the Te Atatu population are Pasifika. During my time as the local MP I have attended countless Pacific community events, and I have shared in church services at the local Pacific churches. After last year’s election my partner and I took Helen Clark and her husband to Samoa for a short break. We stayed at the Sinalei Resort, which is owned by Winnie’s cousins. One of the saddest parts of the visit was attending the funeral for Sinalei owner Tui Annandale. Tui and her husband Joe looked after Helen and I so kindly when we were feeling a bit down over the election result.

Last Wednesday morning I had only just heard about the earthquake and tsunami that had hit Samoa when Winnie called me. Winnie’s offices were being flooded with calls from concerned New Zealand Pacific Islanders who were having real difficulties getting information about their families and loved ones. The phone lines were already very patchy to Samoa. Also, as I made enquiries through my international affairs networks it became quite clear that New Zealand officials didn’t know much more. There was one flight available, Winnie had decided she had to travel to Samoa, she asked me to accompany her, and we both literally rushed to the airport.

One of the things I wanted to do when we arrived in Apia was to visit all of the injured Kiwis in Moto’otua Hospital in Apia. We did that. We took no journalists with us because we just wanted to offer comfort to the victims. Meeting and sitting with the couple from Nelson who had lost their 2 year old was very emotional and hard. People seemed appreciative that we went.

We met many Samoans who had lost loved ones, their homes, all their possessions. It was so tragic.

We also met many holidaying Kiwis who had lost everything – their clothes, money, passports, and who were feeling dazed, exhausted and unsure of how to survive before they were able to head home to New Zealand. Many were camped out at the New Zealand High Commissioner’s residence.

I met a Kiwi teacher from South Auckland, Malcolm Lawrence, a tsunami victim, wandering in the street in Apia with literally nothing except his togs. Malcolm had lost everything including his clothes. He had no credit cards, ID or even cash for food. I gave him my spare clothes and $100 to survive till he was able to get on a flight home. At the High Commission I gave money to another victim, Wendy, from Matamata, who was in a similar situation. Thank goodness they were alive!

It was clear to us that Winnie as Labour’s spokesperson for Pacific Island Affairs, and me as our Foreign Affairs Spokesperson, needed to be there, on the ground, supporting the victims and listening to their plight.

It was important that people felt the humanity and support during a very traumatic time.

It was important for Samoans and holidaying Kiwis to know that the Labour Party cared about the disaster and was quick off the mark to demonstrate its concern.

It is an important role of the Opposition in a Parliamentary democracy to challenge, push and where appropriate support the actions of the government of the day. It is a legitimate role for Opposition MPs to provide a different voice and often alternatives to government policy or action, whether it be in domestic affairs such as Education, Health, Housing or Welfare, or dealing with issues concerning Employers, Workers, Unions, in International Relations/Foreign Affairs, and even in disaster relief.

That’s our job!

It was immediately obvious to us that what Samoa urgently needed was doctors, nurses, immediate food, fresh water supplies and medical equipment.

One thing Winnie and I did discover was that what people in the affected areas really need from now on, is practical household goods, things like sheets, towels, mats, pots, utensils and clothes. With Foreign Aid Samoa will rebuild damaged infrastructure.

Please be generous in donating items for families affected by the tsunami, and please be generous in making donations of money to the disaster relief fund. There are several appeals happening right now. You can donate through the Red Cross, Oxfam, or you can visit ANZ or Westpac bank branches. Many local Pacific churches are also running appeals.

We will send our views to Labour Leader Phil Goff and to Prime Minister John Key, and we will do our best, along with the Labour caucus, to make sure the New Zealand government provides longer term support beyond the immediate relief, for the Samoan victims of the disaster to rebuild their communities and lives.

The challenge for you, is what can you do to help our families and friends in Samoa. Give generously.


Twitter updates from Samoa

Posted by Chris Carter on October 1st, 2009

Phone communications are still very patchy here in Samoa.

Here are my Twitter updates from this afternoon:

CHRIS: We’ve visited most of the devastated sites on Upolu.

CHRIS: Winnie and I have been to NZ High Commission and offered any help we can provide.

CHRIS: Meeting with Samoan Prime Minister again tomorrow.

CHRIS: Winnie and l just visited the 11 injured Kiwis in Apia Hospital. All had horrific stories of survival to tell.

http://www.twitter.com/labourpacific


Shocked by the devastation in Samoa

Posted by Chris Carter on October 1st, 2009

Pacific Island Affairs Spokesperson Luamanuvao Winnie Laban and I are really shocked and distressed by the devastation we’re seeing in Samoa in the aftermath of yesterday’s earthquake and tsunami.

This morning at dawn we attended the funeral of prominent Samoan businesswoman, and much-loved member of Winnie’s family, Tui Annandale. Mrs Annandale attended school and university in New Zealand and owned a resort that was popular with New Zealand tourists.

Right now locals are showing us the devastated south coast of Upolu and Winnie will be meeting more family members. We’re also going to muck in and help with the clean-up, as well as do our best to liaise between families in New Zealand and Samoa.

Samoa’s Prime Minister has requested an urgent meeting to brief us on the situation at 3.30pm today. We’ve already had an informal discussion and been told that shelter and food are important priorities. We’ll be looking to report back to the NZ Government after our meeting.

Telecommunications services into and out of Samoa however remain patchy. To help keep the New Zealand Pacific community in touch with what’s happening here in Samoa we’ll be sending regular Twitter updates throughout the day to http://twitter.com/labourpacific.

We’ll also try to get updates out here on Red Alert.

Winnie is urging New Zealanders to donate generously to organisations collecting to help fund the relief effort. Everyone in Samoa is involved in the huge task of cleaning up in the wake of this disaster, but additional resources are sorely needed. You can go to the Red Cross appeal website or visit ANZ or Westpac bank branches to make a donation.


Turkey and Armenia to establish historic diplomatic ties

Posted by Chris Carter on September 28th, 2009

I’m delighted that Turkey and Armenia will establish diplomatic ties on 10 October.

The countries share a land border in the energy-rich Caspian region, which is often referred to as the gateway between the West and the East.

Turkish-Armenian relations have been strained for a long time. Armenian Christians had fewer rights than the Muslim-majority Turks during the time of the Ottoman Empire. A crisis point was reached in 1915 when many hundreds of thousands of Armenian people died in a very short time. Armenian says a deliberate ‘genocide’ was carried out by Ottoman troops under the orders from the Imperial authorities, but the successor Turkish state adamantly denies there was an official policy of systematic extermination.

Nevertheless, Turkey did recognise Armenia when it declared its independence from the Soviet Union on 1991. Relationships deteriorated when Turkey sided with Azerbaijan during the 1993 Nagarno-Karabakh War. The Armenia-Turkey border has been closed to trade ever since.

I don’t for a moment believe that the historical grievances will be put to rest by this mutual recognition – indeed the move will still require ratification from the respective parliaments in Ankara and Yerevan.

Nonetheless this a very important step forward. Now Turkey and Armenia will have a formalised framework for resolving any points of contention. Also, with the movement of trade and people across the border personal linkages and trust should grow.

So well done to Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan and Armenian President Serzh Sargsian on this historic agreement.